Awqaf New Zealand Working Paper Series
AWQAF NEW ZEALAND · RESEARCH SERIESResearch working paper · Expanded edition · English

From Charitable Waste
to Sustainable Wellbeing

A research framework for unused value in the Qurbani system, and a proposed “Smart Waqf Fund” model for governance, innovation and social development
“We preserve the asset and benefit from its fruit”
Paper index

Contents

  1. 1The Institutional Idea: The Asset and Its Fruit
  2. 2The Qurbani Chain: From Impression to Measurement
  3. 3The Research Farm Model: A System, Not a Single Product
  4. 4Temporary Cash Waqf and Units: The Limits of Knowledge and Compliance
  5. 5Digital Transformation: Administration Is Not a Financial Licence
  6. 6GoSmart: A Knowledge Alliance Before Capital
  7. 7Human Wellbeing: The Final Impact, Not a Slogan
  8. 8The Awqaf Animal Family: Education Through Story
  9. 9The Research Roadmap
  10. 10Methodological Notes and Foundational References
  11. 11Risk Management
  12. 12Seven-Country Comparison
  13. 13Awareness and Artificial Intelligence
  14. 14AAOIFI Standards 14 and 15
  15. 15The Fiqh Question
  16. 16Economic Feasibility
  17. 17Research and Training
  18. 18Publication and Rights
  19. 19References and Documentation
  20. AThe Awqaf New Zealand animal family (images)

List of figures

  1. 1Pillars of the Awqaf animal and farming model
  2. 2The value transformation journey
  3. 3The value chain from the Qurbani animal
  4. 4The Qurbani chain: from impression to measurement
  5. 5The research farm model
  6. 6The waqf unit lifecycle
  7. 7Digital transformation and compliance
  8. 8Research and university collaboration
  9. 9Human wellbeing
  10. 10The Awqaf animal family
  11. 11The research roadmap
  12. 12Methodology and references
  13. 13Risk management
  14. 14The seven jurisdictions under review
  15. 15Artificial intelligence and awareness
  16. 16AAOIFI Standards 14 and 15
  17. 17Temporary cash waqf and qard hasan
  18. 18Economic feasibility analysis
  19. 19From the laboratory to the field to the community
  20. 20The vocational training pathway
  21. 21Scholarly openness and protection of rights
  22. 22Review of evidence and sources
Reading key: the paper distinguishes between published institutional historydocumented factscientific hypothesisfuture conceptpending Sharia or legal decision. All figures are editorial illustrations, not charts based on measured data.
Suggested citation

Benyounis, H. (2026). From Charitable Waste to Sustainable Wellbeing: A Research Framework for Unused Qurbani Value and a Proposed “Smart Waqf Fund” Model (Version 1.0, English edition). Awqaf New Zealand. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874278

DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23874278 · Author: Husain Benyounis (ORCID 0009-0004-9463-5521) · Licence: CC BY-NC 4.0; the Awqaf New Zealand name and logo are excluded from the licence · This English edition is a full translation of the Arabic original.

Research idea

“We preserve the asset and benefit from its fruit”

This paper links Sharia grounding, operational governance, legal characterisation, economic feasibility and social development. It separates established facts, research hypotheses and institutional proposals.

01Unused resources
02Independent scientific testing
03Governance and compliance
04Measurable social benefits
Pillars of the Awqaf animal and farming modelPillars of the Awqaf animal and farming modelShariacomplianceSharia Standard 60 ·Academy Resolution140Research andinnovationIndependent testingof hypothesesEconomicfeasibilityNet benefit, notrevenueProfessionaloperationTraining andempowermentAwarenessand outreachEducation before anyofferGovernanceand riskmanagementAAOIFI GS 14 and 15The asset andits fruitWhat unites the pillarsGovernance and compliance beforeany issuance, and independentresearch free to reject thehypothesesDesign principleWe preserve the asset and benefitfrom its fruit: waqf preservesthe asset, research determinesthe possible fruit!Editorial note: Pillars of a proposed concept for discussion; they do not imply existing Sharia or regulatory approval.
Figure 1 Pillars of the Awqaf animal and farming modelEditorial illustration · not measured data
PART ONE

The Framework and the Model

Chapters 1–10

Chapter 01 / Idea and approach

1 | The Institutional Idea: The Asset and Its Fruit

Status of this study: a research working paper open to critique and review. It is not a fatwa, a legal opinion, an offer document or an invitation to participate financially. According to the institution’s published work, no waqf units are offered in any jurisdiction. The results of the regulatory comparisons depend on final characterisation and local verification. Scholarly publication does not equal permission for financial marketing.
01Unused value
02Independent research and measurement
03Sharia and legal structure
04Sustainable benefit

GoSmart links three levels: rediscovering the value wasted in the Qurbani system, exploring waqf as a tool for sustaining benefits, and then directing those benefits to human wellbeing in a multidimensional sense. This is a proposed line of reasoning, not automatic proof that each link has been achieved in practice.

Design principle

The image of roots and fruit is used to illustrate sustainability, and the educational animal illustrations are used in the awareness chapter only, while the legal and Sharia analysis pages remain calm, documented and free of marketing suggestion.

The logic of value transformation

The study starts from a specific institutional hypothesis: charitable value chains may contain resources or productive opportunities that do not yield sufficient benefit, and scientific research and disciplined management can determine whether recovering that value is possible, permissible and worthwhile. It is not enough to describe a resource as “wasted” before defining the baseline, the data source and the method of measurement.

The value transformation journeyThe value transformation journeyUnused charitableresourcesMoney, animals, knowledge,time, by-productsResearch,innovation andpartnershipsIndependent measurement,trials, technology, trainingPotential waqfrevenueUnits and productive assetsonly after approvalSustainablewellbeingEducation, health, communityempowermentThree concepts that must not be added into one figurePhysical wasteCan be observed and measuredAlternative production opportunityRequires economic comparisonWaqf returnAfter costs, once the structure is proven sound!Editorial note: A conceptual diagram, not proof of realised economic results.
Figure 2 The value transformation journeyEditorial illustration · not measured data

A distinction is needed here between three concepts: physical waste, which can be observed; alternative production opportunity, which requires economic comparison; and waqf return, which is only realised after deducting costs and proving the soundness of the contractual structure. These categories must not be added together into a single figure.

Chapter 02 / Measuring resources

2 | The Qurbani Chain: From Impression to Measurement

01Before Eid
02Slaughter
03Carcass recovery
04The fifth quarter
05Distribution
06Forgone productive life

GoSmart v11 sets out a proposed method for measuring utilisation across six stages. It stresses that the method contains no actual measurement results, and that the productive opportunity not realised during the animal’s life is not physical loss in the same sense. Field data, not illustrations, must therefore be the basis for estimating the size of the problem.

The value chain from the Qurbani animalThe value chain from the Qurbani animal1MeatFood and charitable distribution2SkinsIndustries and supply pathways3WoolTextiles and spinning4Offal and by-productsThe fifth quarter: use to be measured5Loss in transport and storageCold chain tracking6Alternative productive lifeOpportunity cost, not physical loss!Editorial note: Pathways to be measured in the field; alternative productive life is an opportunity cost, not physical loss.
Figure 3 The value chain from the Qurbani animalEditorial illustration · not measured data

Proposed research outputs

A loss classification guide, a data collection protocol, a full cost model, alternative scenarios and sensitivity analysis. Limitations and negative results must be published as clearly as supporting results.

StageMeasurement questionType of evidence required
Holding before EidWhat resources are used and what is lost?Operational records
SlaughterWhat are the inputs and outputs?Scales and records
Carcass recoveryWhat share of the parts is utilised?Weight data
The fifth quarterHow are skins, offal and other parts used?Supply pathways
DistributionWhat is lost in transport and storage?Cold chain tracking
Forgone productive lifeWhat alternatives exist for herd management?Modelling of an alternative opportunity, not physical loss

The Qurbani Utilisation Index (QUI) method

GoSmart v11 proposes dividing the Qurbani chain into six research stages: before Eid, slaughter, recovery of carcass components, use of by-products, distribution, and finally the productive life the animal may forgo. The last stage represents an alternative opportunity cost, not physical loss, and must be kept separate from indicators borrowed from food loss methodologies.

The Qurbani chain: from impression to measurementThe Qurbani chain: from impression to measurementSix stages of measurement (proposed method, no actual results yet)1Before EidHousing and resources2SlaughterInputs and outputs3CarcassUsable parts4By-productsWool, skins and others5DistributionQuantity, quality, reach6Productive lifeSeparate alternative opportunityStages 1–5: physical loss that can be observedStage 6: opportunity cost, modelled separately!Editorial note: Stage six is an opportunity cost, not physical loss.
Figure 4 The Qurbani chain: from impression to measurementEditorial illustration · not measured data

Each stage needs an operational definition, a unit of measurement and an independent party to collect data. Any inference about the scale of global waste from a single local project would be insufficient without a representative sample design.

Chapter 03 / The farming system

3 | The Research Farm Model: A System, Not a Single Product

The educational images of the animal family characters appear in the awareness chapter, not as images of the research farm or as scientific evidence.

The programme proposes testing the integration of dairy production, herd management, Qurbani timing and the use of wool, skins and by-products, while assessing animal health and welfare, the efficiency of land and water use, and commercial feasibility. The Qurbani and dairy farm is at the concept and feasibility stage and is not an operating project.

The research farm modelThe research farm modelResearch farm(concept andfeasibility)Herd managementScheduling by the Hijri calendarDairy productionProduction, health and costQurbani timingCalendar and management alignmentWool, skins andby-productsNet, not gross, benefitAnimal health andwelfareIndependent welfare protocolLand and waterefficiencyand commercial feasibilityTestable hypotheses, not an operating project!Editorial note: All elements are hypotheses or experimental pathways, not proven results.
Figure 5 The research farm modelEditorial illustration · not measured data

A distinction should be made between aligning management with the Hijri calendar as an operational choice, and any hypothesis about the effect of lunar phases on reproduction, which is a biological question requiring independent testing.

Testing the farming hypothesis without pre-empting the results

The concept rests on the possibility of aligning breeding, lambing and milking with the movement of Eid al-Adha through the solar year. This is a proposed calendar and management alignment; it does not establish any physiological effect of lunar phases. Experimental questions include breed variation, nutrition, animal welfare, fertility rates, production timing and scalability.

Testable hypothesisTest indicatorMethodological constraint
Feasibility of scheduling the flock by the Hijri calendarLambings, gestation periods, regularity of supplyAlternatives compared across different seasons
Feasibility of combining dairy and Qurbani productionProduction, health, welfare, costFeasibility is not assumed before an independent trial
Improving resource utilisationMain products, by-products and costsNet, not gross, benefit
Chapter 04 / Units and governance

4 | Temporary Cash Waqf and Units: The Limits of Knowledge and Compliance

The waqf unit lifecycleThe waqf unit lifecycleThe waqf unit(proposed concept)First: Sharia and legal approval1Donor (waqif)Acknowledges risk and waqf conditions2FundSegregated funds and oversight3ProjectFlows and reports4MaturitySettlement by contract and resultsWhat must be settled before any issuanceSharia groundingDonor’s rights definedGovernance and oversightLegal classificationRegulator review!Editorial note: No offer or issuance before the structure and required licences are approved.
Figure 6 The waqf unit lifecycleEditorial illustration · not measured data

Waqf units are a concept for making participation and digital administration easier, but they do not acquire legal or Sharia status merely by being called units. The fiqh distinction between temporary cash waqf and qard hasan remains under consideration by the relevant fiqh forum, and the outcome must not be presented as settled.

The proposed governance draws on AAOIFI GS 14 on Islamic crowdfunding where relevant, while GS 15 is considered if co-financing between institutions emerges later. Neither replaces the laws of New Zealand or the local laws of other countries.

IssueWhat must be settled before any issuance
Sharia characterisationThe nature of temporary waqf, the donor’s rights and the return of the principal
Legal characterisationDoes a contractual right to recover the money arise? Is it a financial product?
Custody and segregationTrusteeship, separate accounts and beneficiaries’ interests
DisclosureRisks, term, uses, and no unfounded guarantee of return or principal
TechnologyDocumentation, privacy, security, oversight and transaction records

Unit lifecycle and the rights of the parties

What a “unit” is must be defined in every document: is it evidence of a waqf contribution, a share in a pool, a contractual right to recover an amount, or something else? This definition determines the rights and obligations and how a shortfall is handled at the end of the term. It is proposed that the wording be tested through four separate documents: the donor’s deed, the funds management policy, the project agreement and the maturity and redemption document.

Speaking of “best endeavours” to recover the principal does not on its own determine the legal classification; the substance of the binding right is examined in each country, bearing in mind that, according to Awqaf New Zealand, the fiqh question is still before the 12th Forum.

Chapter 05 / Digital transformation

5 | Digital Transformation: Administration Is Not a Financial Licence

Digital transformation and complianceDigital transformation and complianceInformation management layer1Data entry2Verification andapproval3Documentation4Monitoring5Disclosure andclosureMandatory separation of the two layersMoney, custody and settlement layerAccepting fundsThrough a qualified provider where the lawrequiresCustodySeparate accounts and trusteeshipSettlementNot assumed permitted just because aplatform existsMinimum: clear permissions · audit log · dual approval · incident and recovery procedures!Editorial note: Google for Nonprofits tools are not a financial licence.
Figure 7 Digital transformation and complianceEditorial illustration · not measured data

Google for Nonprofits tools can help with online forms, documentation, correspondence, monitoring dashboards and task allocation. But using these tools does not mean they automatically provide regulated custody of funds, licensed payment processing or compliance with securities laws.

Minimum design: clear permissions, an audit log, dual approval for sensitive actions, separation of data from financial accounts, and procedures for incidents, correction and recovery.

Separating digital administration from regulated financial services

Google for Nonprofits tools can help with forms, correspondence, databases, documentation, monitoring and reporting, but they are not in themselves a licence to issue financial instruments, hold others’ money or provide regulated payment services. The information management layer must therefore be separated from the money, custody and settlement layer, and the latter linked to qualified service providers where the law requires it.

Administration

The digital pathway

Identity, approvals, documents, notifications, records, reports.

Protection

Technical governance

Permissions, backups, information security, incident response.

Regulation

Potential financial services

Accepting, holding and settling funds is not assumed to be permitted merely because an administrative platform exists.

Chapter 06 / Scientific partnerships

6 | GoSmart: A Knowledge Alliance Before Capital

Research and university collaborationResearch and university collaborationIndependent research questions put to universitiesMethod and data for independent measurementLimited, falsifiable testingPublishing negative and positive resultsInstitutional decision after scientific evaluationDocumenting the status of each relationship (endorsement is not assumed)ContactDiscussionInvitationProposed projectSigned agreementImplementation!Editorial note: The alliance is proposed for consultation; it does not imply partners’ endorsement or agreement.
Figure 8 Research and university collaborationEditorial illustration · not measured data

The eleventh version describes GoSmart as an open knowledge alliance at the consultation and design stage. The appearance of a university or institution’s name in the document does not mean its final endorsement or agreement to take part. Nor does the document create a financial offer or funding for the farm.

The structure of research collaboration

Important elements include allowing independent research that can reject the project’s hypotheses; crediting scientific concepts to their originators; and documenting the stages of institutional approval before using partners’ names or launching joint initiatives.

Building partnerships, not assuming them

The initiative proposes a chain of collaboration that begins by putting falsifiable questions to universities, then developing an independent measurement method, then limited testing, then published scientific evaluation. Vocational training providers are asked to turn the required skills into recognised learning units where possible, giving priority to groups with the fewest training and employment opportunities.

In documenting contact with Charles Sturt University, the University of Waikato and other bodies, the status and date of the relationship are stated precisely: contact, discussion, invitation, proposed project, signed agreement or actual implementation. The appearance of a university’s name in GoSmart v11 does not mean it has agreed to fund or carry out any work.

Chapter 07 / Social impact

7 | Human Wellbeing: The Final Impact, Not a Slogan

01Established resources
02Legitimate activity
03Social outputs
04Measurable impact

Proving agricultural productivity is not enough to prove human wellbeing. An independent measurement framework should be developed that links, where possible, waqf resources to indicators such as learning, vocational skills, economic capacity, social connection and health. Direct outputs should be kept separate from long-term outcomes.

Human wellbeingHuman wellbeingThe logic chain of impact1ResourcesEstablished2ActivitiesLegitimate3OutputsCourses or studies completed4OutcomesSkills, moving into work5ImpactSustained, measured over timeCandidate Sustainable Development Goals (alignment set before publication)SDG2SDG4SDG8SDG9SDG12SDG17!Editorial note: Outcomes to be measured, not proven impacts.
Figure 9 Human wellbeingEditorial illustration · not measured data
LevelExample indicatorMethodological caution
OutputNumber of trainees or learning materialsDoes not equal a change in wellbeing
Intermediate outcomeSkill gained or income improvedNeeds a baseline and comparison
Long-term impactSustained improvement in one dimension of wellbeingNeeds long-term independent evaluation

From activity indicators to impact indicators

Counting units, views or trainees is not enough. The logic chain should be tracked: resources → activities → outputs → outcomes → impact, identifying what can be attributed to Awqaf New Zealand’s intervention and what is influenced by external factors.

LevelExample indicatorMeans of verification
OutputsNumber of courses or studies completedRecords and published outputs
OutcomesImproved skills or transition to workBefore/after assessment and follow-up
ImpactSustained improvement in income, food or resourcesLongitudinal measurement and suitable comparison

Candidate indicators relate to Sustainable Development Goals 2, 4, 8, 9, 12 and 17. The alignment of each indicator with the appropriate sub-target is to be set before publication, without claiming impact that has not been measured.

Chapter 08 / Learning through illustration

8 | The Awqaf Animal Family: Education Through Story

The Awqaf New Zealand animal family
The Awqaf New Zealand Animal Family
Awareness page · a fictional story, not research findings
Meet the Awqaf Animal Family, collection 1 of 4
The original characters of the educational initiative, a concept for raising awareness of values and resources.
The ewe
The ewe: farm leadership, dairy learning and practical care
The honeybee
The honeybee: pollination, productive work and cooperation

The animal and bee characters are used to introduce ideas of care, production, cooperation and not wasting resources, while introducing children to the names of animals and their habitats in different countries. The episodes should not reduce the Qurbani to a commodity or suggest that financial return is its devotional purpose.

A sample short episode

The episode opens with a ewe on an imaginary farm who notices that some of her wool is being lost. She asks the bees and the farmer for help to learn how it can be used. It ends with an open question for children about the value of resources and kindness to animals. This is a proposed educational story, not a description of an existing project.

An educational story, not a financial appeal to children

The animal family is built on characters, each linked to a country, a natural environment and a skill or value. This structure allows short episodes that explain cooperation, kindness to animals and wise use of resources, and introduce viewers to countries and animals. Education for children is kept completely separate from any financial promotion of waqf units; financial invitations should be directed to adults within the limits of the law and approvals.

The Awqaf animal familyThe Awqaf animal familyStructure of a short educational episode1A loveable characterAn animal and a country2A story problemWaste or lack of cooperation3A responsible solutionResearch and cooperation4A practical lessonValues and behaviourEducation for families and childrenCooperation · kindness to animals · wise use of resourcesFinancial promotion to adults onlyWithin law and approvals, and kept fully separate!Editorial note: Awareness illustrations; fictional stories must be kept separate from research findings.
Figure 10 The Awqaf animal familyEditorial illustration · not measured data
Chapter 09 / Implementation pathway

9 | The Research Roadmap

01Publication and critique
02Independent verification
03Sharia opinion
04Legal characterisation
05Detailed design
06Decision of the competent bodies
The research roadmap: six sequential stages with conditions for moving on, no binding dates
Figure 11 The research roadmapEditorial illustration · not measured data
StageOutputCondition for moving on
1. Clarifying conceptsA glossary of terms and a source fileInstitutional review
2. Measuring lossAn independent method and field dataValidity of the data
3. Testing feasibilityTechnical, financial and environmental scenariosScientific verification
4. CharacterisationSharia and legal reviewDecisions of the competent bodies
5. Operational designGovernance, technology and agreementsApprovals and accreditations
6. Measuring impactWellbeing indicators and an independent reportVerifiable results
Chapter 10 / References and limits

10 | Methodological Notes and Foundational References

Methodology and referencesMethodology and referencesLadder of evidence strength (editorial classification for this paper)Approved official textLegislation, Academy resolution, standard in its official editionPublished study or documentISRA 2016 study, papers deposited with a DOIInstitutional documentAwqaf New Zealand website, Maliki forum paperUnpublished consultation documentGoSmart v11: a conceptual framework, not approvalHypothesis or future conceptProposed scenarios and partnershipsStrongerWeaker!Editorial note: A scholarly reference is required for every substantive claim.
Figure 12 Methodology and referencesEditorial illustration · not measured data

1. GoSmart v11, “Global Open Smart Waqf”, version of 30 September 2026, an unpublished consultation document; used here to define the conceptual framework and verification cases, not as final approval by the bodies named.

2. Awqaf New Zealand, “Engineering the Awqaf Industry”, https://awqafnz.org/engineering/en.html, an institutional reference defining the project and its development; the latest update must be checked before publication.

3. AAOIFI, Governance Standard GS 14: Islamic Crowdfunding Governance, and GS 15: Syndicated Financing, supporting governance references that do not replace a qualified legal or Sharia opinion.

4. The proposed method for measuring utilisation in the Qurbani chain referred to in GoSmart v11; not a set of published results or evidence of the scale of global waste.

5. All economic, farming and future partnership scenarios in this paper remain research proposals unless accompanied by approval documents and independent verification results.

Next editorial step: complete the reference appendices, verify the legislative texts in each jurisdiction, and include purpose-drawn infographics for each chapter with a list of figures and data sources.

PART TWO

Supporting Research Files

Risk · Regulatory comparison · Awareness · Standards · Fiqh · Feasibility · Research · Rights · Sources

Additional research file / Risk management

Risk Management in the Smart Waqf Fund Concept

Awqaf New Zealand proposes studying several layers of risk management, including takaful insurance where available and permissible, an independent third-party guarantee where its Sharia and legal conditions are met, consideration of eligibility for zakat for debtors (al-gharimin) under its rules, and the donor’s acknowledgement of risk at the time of contracting. These mechanisms are not automatic substitutes for capital and do not mean its recovery is guaranteed.

Risk managementRisk managementShariaDiffering characterisationLegalUnit classed as a regulated productLiquidityMaturities coincidingCreditProject or guarantor defaultOperationalRecord and payment errorsAgriculturalFlock disease and feedTechnologyData leaksReputation & marketingRead as an offerProposed layers of protectionPreventionFeasibility, diversification, oversightMitigationTakaful or guarantee, if permittedResponseHandling default and disclosureResidual riskInformed acknowledgement by the donor!Editorial note: Likelihood, impact and ownership are added after expert review; recovery of the principal is not guaranteed.
Figure 13 Risk managementEditorial illustration · not measured data

A distinction is needed between an enforceable contractual obligation, an undertaking to use reasonable care, a donation and an independent guarantee. This area remains a proposal for fiqh and legal investigation.

Multi-layer protection design and stress tests

Awqaf New Zealand’s concept relies on several possible risk mitigation mechanisms: takaful, an independent third-party guarantee, research into whether the rules of zakat for debtors apply when their conditions are met, and the donor’s acknowledgement of risk, together with oversight, diversification and reserves where permissible. These mechanisms are not interchangeable or guaranteed to be available; each has its own conditions, costs and limits of enforceability.

ScenarioPossible responseLimit that must be disclosed
Animal deaths or a covered lossTakaful claim if the conditions of cover are metExclusions and limits of compensation
Project defaults on repaymentReview of the independent guarantee and reservesSolvency of the guarantor and enforceability of the undertaking
Uncovered lossActivating remediation procedures under the contractThe donor may bear loss of the principal
Request for support from zakat fundsIndependent assessment of the debtor’s eligibilityNot an automatic or guaranteed source of funding

A separation is required between the donor bearing investment risk and the nazir’s (trustee’s) liability for negligence, misconduct or breach of contract; acknowledgement of risk must not be read as a blanket release from liability.

Proposed risk register for the Smart Waqf Fund

Risk categoryEvent or cause of lossProposed treatmentEvidence required
ShariaDiffering characterisation of temporary waqf and qard hasan, or of the guaranteeNot pre-empting the Forum; reviewing contracts and Sharia decisionsA qualified fatwa and a register of decisions
LegalThe unit classified as a debt instrument or regulated productA legal opinion for each market before promotionA written characterisation memo
LiquidityUnit maturities coinciding with delayed project revenueModelling maturity dates and a liquidity reserve where permissibleStress test and cash flow forecast
CreditDefault by the project or the independent guarantorSolvency assessment, exposure limits, a permissible independent guaranteeThird-party assessment and guarantee wording
OperationalRecord errors or funds spent outside their purposesSegregation of duties, review and reconciliationAudit trail and regular reconciliations
AgriculturalFlock disease, volatile feed prices or production shortfallVeterinary care, contingency plans, conditional takafulWelfare protocol and sensitivity calculation
TechnologyData leak, loss of records or account compromiseLeast privilege, backups, incident responseSecurity test and continuity plan
Reputation and marketingEducational content understood as an invitation to subscribeSeparating children’s content from financial offersEditorial policy and compliance approval

Likelihood, impact, owner, actions and review date are assessed for each risk before operations begin. The existence of takaful or a guarantor does not automatically turn the return or the principal into a guaranteed amount, nor may zakat for debtors be treated as automatic compensation for business risk.

Comparative appendix / Jurisdiction of first issuance

Preliminary Comparison of Seven Jurisdictions

The following comparison is a research checklist, not a final ranking of countries, a fatwa or a legal opinion. The choice depends on the true nature of the unit’s rights, the issuer, the location of the contributor and cross-border marketing.

The seven jurisdictions under reviewThe seven jurisdictions under reviewNew ZealandFMAAustraliaASIC · ACNCCanadaProvincial regulators · CRAUnited KingdomFCA · Charity CommissionKuwaitKuwait Awqaf Public Foundation · Capital Markets AuthorityBahrainCentral Bank of BahrainMalaysiaSecurities Commission · State Religious Councils!Editorial note: A map of regulatory questions only; no ranking or assessment of legal suitability, with a separate memo for each jurisdiction.
Figure 14 The seven jurisdictions under reviewEditorial illustration · not measured data
CountryFirst area of inquiryBody or framework requiring verification
New ZealandDoes a right to recover the amount arise, and how is the product classified?Financial Markets Conduct Act / FMA
AustraliaOffer of a financial product or credit, and the limits of exemptionsCorporations Act / ASIC
CanadaSecurities requirements differ by provinceProvincial securities regulators
United KingdomClassification of the activity, the offer and financial promotionFCA / Financial Services and Markets Act
KuwaitWaqf, the competent authority and whether an offer is possibleThe competent waqf and regulatory bodies
BahrainCrowdfunding and Islamic financial productsCentral Bank of Bahrain
MalaysiaState jurisdiction over waqf, and regulation of fundraisingWaqf authorities and the Securities Commission where applicable

No cell should be read as approval to issue or as the existence of an exemption. An independent legal memo is required for each jurisdiction before recommending a first country.

Method for choosing the jurisdiction of first issuance

The seven countries are assessed on a single matrix, not on reputation or institutional proximity alone. The assessment begins with the legal characterisation of the right of recovery, then the need for a licence, then the possibility of cross-border marketing, then cost, time, governance and the waqf environment. The place where the entity is established, where the project operates and where the donor lives are treated separately.

Decision criterionScreening questionType of evidence
ClassificationDoes the unit create a debt security, a financial product or a different charitable arrangement?Statutory text and a local legal opinion
IssuanceIs a licence, disclosure or an independent trustee required?The regulator and legislation
MarketingWho may be approached, and in which country?Rules on cross-border offers
FeasibilityWhat are the cost, time and institutional capacity?Verifiable quotes and estimates

This version contains no final ranking of New Zealand, Australia, Canada, the United Kingdom, Kuwait, Bahrain or Malaysia; that requires current formal legislative research and local review before any operational recommendation is made.

Detailed comparative reading: seven jurisdictions

The following comparison is a map of regulatory questions, not a legal opinion or a licence to issue. It must be applied to at least two contractual versions: (a) a unit granting a binding right to the return of the principal, and (b) a unit where the return of the principal depends on the project’s result and best endeavours. A difference in wording alone does not guarantee a different legal outcome.

CountryRegulatory entry pointDecisive issuePrimary body or reference
New ZealandFinancial Markets Conduct Act 2013, together with rules on charities and trustsA right to repayment may fall within the definition of a debt security even without interest; the enforceable right, the nature of the pool and any applicable exemptions must be examinedOfficial legislation; Financial Markets Authority (FMA)
AustraliaCorporations Act 2001, disclosure and financial services rules, and state fundraising legislationIs the unit a security, a managed investment scheme or a donation? What is the effect of advertising to the public in each state?ASIC; ACNC; state fundraising regulators
CanadaProvincial securities laws, and federal and provincial charity and tax regulationRules differ between provinces; does the unit represent a debt obligation or an investment contract?Canadian Securities Administrators; provincial regulators; CRA
United KingdomFCA rules and the Financial Services and Markets Act, and charity law by nationDistinguishing charitable activity from regulated financial activity, the substance of the right of recovery, and promotional communicationsFCA; Charity Commission for England and Wales
KuwaitRegulation of waqf, charities and financial markets, together with the relevant government mandatesThe body authorised to establish the pool and issue its units, the scope of the awaited fiqh decision, and the nature of marketing to individualsKuwait Awqaf Public Foundation; Capital Markets Authority; competent bodies
BahrainCentral Bank of Bahrain rules and the regulation of financial institutions and waqfDoes the structure require a licensed institution or an approved arrangement for custody and distribution, and how is Sharia governance applied?Central Bank of Bahrain (CBB); waqf bodies
MalaysiaSecurities Commission rules, regulation of digital markets, and state-level waqf mandatesDetermining jurisdiction between the state waqf body and the federal financial regulator, and characterisation before choosing a funding platformSecurities Commission Malaysia; State Islamic Religious Councils

At this stage there is not enough evidence to give the seven countries an objective numerical ranking. The final comparison is only fit for a decision once local consultations, cost, time and cross-border marketability are complete. A distinction is always kept between the country where the pool is established, the country of the project and the country where the participant lives.

Applied file / Media and innovation

Multilingual Awareness and Artificial Intelligence

Awqaf New Zealand is exploring animation and animal characters as a way to teach the values of cooperation, care and responsible use of resources. Artificial intelligence helps with drafting, translation and design, while verification, editing and intellectual property remain human responsibilities.

Artificial intelligence and awarenessArtificial intelligence and awarenessIllustrative future concept · values in the image are hypothetical · the farm does not exist yetProposed monitoring of herd health, pasture, water and energyDrafting, translation, design and multilingual storiesWaqf education before any offer of unitsHuman review of facts, references and rightsImpact, privacy and platform terms assessedThe path of awareness and trust before any offerEducationStories and explanationDialogueWorking papers and critiqueTrustResults and independent auditRegulated offerOnly once requirements are met!Editorial note: Image rights, privacy and platform terms must be checked; no subscription invitations in educational content.
Figure 15 Artificial intelligence and awarenessEditorial illustration · not measured data

General awareness aimed at families must be clearly separated from financial promotion aimed at adults; no offer of units begins before the relevant requirements are met.

Awareness channel: youtube.com/@AwqafNewZealand

The full Awqaf animal family character collections are in the image appendix at the end of the paper.

The path of awareness and trust before any offer

Responsible marketing begins with education about waqf, then publishing working papers and areas of uncertainty, then listening to scholarly critique, and only moves to offering units for participation after the structure’s Sharia validity and legal status in the target markets have been verified. The YouTube channel and animated content can serve the first, educational stage without invitations to subscribe or promises of repayment.

The role of artificial intelligence in initial research, editing, translation, design and production is documented, with human review of facts, references and rights, and the output is not described as “approved” or “peer reviewed” merely because the technology was used.

Standards axis / AAOIFI

AAOIFI Standards: From Sharia Control to Practical Governance

Governance Standard No. 14 is examined as the main reference for the governance of Islamic crowdfunding, including disclosure, contributor protection, separation of responsibilities, Sharia oversight and management of digital operations. Governance Standard No. 15 deals with syndicated financing, and becomes relevant if the model moves to financing in which several institutions take part; it is not assumed to apply automatically to every individual unit.

GS 14

Participation governance

Operator identity, independent custody, disclosure, Sharia review, complaints, technical risk.

GS 15

Joint institutional financing

Arrangements between institutions, coordinator powers, default management, conflicts of interest.

Decisive condition

Local law

AAOIFI standards do not replace licensing or legal obligations in the country of issuance or marketing.

The final reference version needs a precise clause-by-clause matrix linking the text of each standard to the corresponding contractual and operational clause in the model, with review of the official approved edition.

AAOIFI Standards 14 and 15AAOIFI Standards 14 and 15Scope of application: each standard has its own fieldGS 14Governance of Islamic crowdfundingOperator identityIndependent custodyDisclosureSharia reviewDigital securityGS 15Syndicated financing between institutionsCoordinator powersRelations between financiersDefault managementConflicts of interestOnly where there are several financiersLocal lawA decisive condition the standards do not replaceLicensingRegulatory disclosureMarketing rulesCountry of issuanceParticipant’s countryGS 13 (waqf governance) added to the review · clause-by-clause conformity needs the approved texts!Editorial note: The standards are not a licence to issue and do not apply automatically.
Figure 16 AAOIFI Standards 14 and 15Editorial illustration · not measured data

A practical application matrix for the two standards

AreaWhat to examine under GS 14Relevance of GS 15Document required
Identity and responsibilityRole of the platform operator and the partiesCoordinator of institutional financing, where there is oneGovernance structure and contracts
FundsCustody, segregation and oversightAllocation of obligations between financiersCustody and settlement agreement
DisclosureRisks, terms and informationDisclosure between parties to syndicated financingKey information document
Sharia oversightReview, decisions and correctionHandling differences in institutional arrangementsRegister of decisions and independent review
DigitisationSystem security and information protectionCoordinating records where there are several partiesSecurity and privacy policy

This is a preliminary thematic matrix, not a certificate of conformity. Before final publication, the paragraph numbers of both standards and their approved texts must be included, and each obligation linked to an operational clause and evidence of verification.

Testing applicability, not claiming conformity

Governance Standard 14 addresses governance in Islamic crowdfunding and is a suitable starting point for designing the operator’s role, separating participants’ funds, disclosure, Sharia oversight, reporting and digital security. That some of its principles apply does not mean the waqf structure conforms to the standard in full. Standard 15 covers syndicated financing between institutions and becomes relevant when there are several institutional financiers or the transaction requires a coordinator and an agreement between financiers.

Before receiving fundsSharia and legal characterisation, identity of the parties, contract review, custody plan, disclosures
During operationSegregation of funds, reporting, audit, risk register, oversight of conflicts of interest
At maturityVerifying results, liquidity, rights and guarantees, handling complaints, redemption and documentation

Alongside these two standards, the Waqf Governance Standard GS 13 is included in the review of references, with the scope of each standard distinguished. The final conformity matrix requires going back to the approved texts of the standards clause by clause, not relying on titles or general commentary.

Fiqh axis / Open questions

Temporary Cash Waqf and Qard Hasan: The Limits of the Research

This section presents the history of the study of temporary cash waqf and the fiqh views on time limits, recovery and guarantees, drawing on Resolution No. 140 (15/6) of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy, AAOIFI Sharia Standard No. 60, Awqaf New Zealand’s paper to the Maliki forum, and the historical study published by ISRA in 2016.

Temporary cash waqf and qard hasanTemporary cash waqf and qard hasanNeighbouring questions, not a single questionTemporarycash waqf andqard hasanIs endowing cashpermissible?Is a time limitpermissible?Returning theprincipalUsing the money forinvestment or lendingLimits of guaranteeHistorically established: an earlier study and structureUnder consideration: before the 12th ForumUnresolved: no new approval attributed!Editorial note: An open question; the 12th Forum on Waqf Fiqh Issues is not pre-empted.
Figure 17 Temporary cash waqf and qard hasanEditorial illustration · not measured data
Historically establishedAn earlier study and structure for waqf sukuk, and historical endorsements whose original scope should be documented.
Under considerationThe fiqh differences between temporary cash waqf and cash qard hasan are before the 12th Forum at Awqaf New Zealand’s request, according to the institution.
UnresolvedNo new approval of the current version of the units is attributed to scholars, the Forum or regulators.

The purpose of this section is to document where the difficulty lies and the scope for ijtihad, not to issue a fiqh ruling parallel to the Forum’s process or to pre-empt its decision.

Map of deferred fiqh questions

The research should distinguish between whether endowing cash is permissible in principle, whether a time limit is permissible, the ruling on returning the principal to the donor, the effect of using the money for investment or lending, and the limits of guarantee. These are neighbouring questions, not one question. Resolution No. 140, Sharia Standard 60 and the 2016 ISRA study are presented within their context and time frame, without attributing approval of the current structure to them.

What is the nature of the money?Money endowed temporarily, a debt that must be repaid, or another arrangement?
What is the effect of the term?What happens at the end of the waqf, and when a loss occurs?
Who bears responsibility?The donor, the nazir, the guarantor or the project, according to the contract, Sharia and the law.
Feasibility / Impact economics

Economic Feasibility: Does Recovered Value Become a Sustainable Benefit?

The study is built on a general model that can be applied in more than one sector, and its hypotheses are then tested in the proposed Qurbani sheep and dairy project. It separates potential revenue from the costs of operation, governance, takaful, guarantees, training and research, and tests sensitivity to volatility, default and demand.

1A documented baseline of resources and loss
2Full cost of the unit lifecycle
3Scenario tests and cash flows
4Verifiable social impact
Assessment questionIndicator or document requiredState of knowledge
How much of the resource is unused?Independent measurement using the Qurbani chain and the QUI indexProposed method; data not yet established
Is the activity sustainable?Costs, revenue, working capital, stress testsNeeds a trial and data
Is social benefit generated?Training, employment, food and waste reductionTarget indicators, not achieved results

Hypothetical figures are not used as confirmed global statistics, and the animal’s forgone productive life is not confused with actual physical loss.

The feasibility equation and sensitivity tests

It is proposed that the feasibility criterion be sustainable net benefit after deducting full costs, not gross revenue. The calculation includes the costs of data collection, trials, animal welfare, operations, insurance, governance, audit, marketing, compliance and training.

Economic feasibility analysisEconomic feasibility analysisVerifiablerevenue−Operating costs−Governance andcompliance−Risk provisions=Net economicvalue???Stress scenario???Base scenario???Optimistic scenarioEmpty template to be filled from the independent field study · no hypothetical figuresVerifiable revenueFull costsNet benefit!Editorial note: No figures or expected returns without independent data; the template awaits measurement results.
Figure 18 Economic feasibility analysisEditorial illustration · not measured data

At least three scenarios must be tested: base, stress and optimistic, stating the assumptions and their sources. The tables are not filled with undocumented figures; they are prepared as templates ready to receive the results of the independent field study.

A testable feasibility template

Measurement itemData requiredVerification method
Comparative baselineCosts and returns in the existing Qurbani systemAn independent field study and documented comparison
Alternative scenarioDairy, breeding, welfare, slaughter, by-productsA limited trial under veterinary controls
Full costsFeed, labour, training, insurance, compliance, transport, marketingInvoices and estimates with stated assumptions
RisksDeaths, disease, price volatility, delayed maturitySensitivity analysis and stress scenarios
Social impactSkills, employment, food, waste reductionBaseline and follow-up over time

The theoretical value of by-products must not be added to realised revenue; there may be processing costs, marketing barriers or health requirements that make the net value far lower than the gross value. Likewise, extending an animal’s productive life is not “food loss”; it is a separate economic question about the alternative opportunity.

Research and training / Partnerships

From the Laboratory to the Field to the Community

Awqaf New Zealand seeks to engage with universities to test the hypotheses independently, and in parallel with vocational training providers to prepare people from groups with the least academic and vocational opportunity. The Hijri-calendar-aligned breeding and dairy project is presented as an experimental research framework, not a proven production protocol.

From the laboratory to the field to the communityFrom the laboratory to the field to the communityThe applied research journey1UniversitiesTesting hypotheses2Pilot projectData and practices3Vocational trainingSkills and opportunities4Community wellbeingMeasured resultsSDG 4Quality educationSDG 8Decent workSDG 12Responsible productionScientific trials kept separate from commercial operation · researchers’ right to independent conclusions!Editorial note: Scientific trials are kept separate from commercial application.
Figure 19 From the laboratory to the field to the communityEditorial illustration · not measured data

The research should state precisely the status of each institutional relationship: contact, discussion, research invitation, memorandum of understanding or approved project. University names are not presented as implementing partners unless there is evidence of this.

SDG 4

Quality education

Training outputs and verifiable skills.

SDG 8

Decent work

Moving from training into work and income opportunities.

SDG 12

Responsible production

Resource efficiency and loss reduction based on independent measurement.

The vocational training pathwayThe vocational training pathwayUnited KingdomThe vet foxGermanyHoneybeeCzechiaRed squirrelOutreachLeast-advantagedgroupsPreparationEntry conditions andaccess supportPracticaltrainingWith qualifiedprovidersEmploymentPathways into workTraining separate from commercial operation · researchers’ right to independent conclusions · recognised qualifications where possible!Editorial note: A proposed pathway; the production project is not assumed to be an accredited training provider.
Figure 20 The vocational training pathwayEditorial illustration · not measured data

Vocational equity and independent evaluation

Real participation by groups with the least academic and vocational opportunity requires setting entry conditions, training costs, options for recognising qualifications, access support and pathways into work. Training units are best designed with qualified vocational institutions rather than assuming the production project itself is an accredited training provider.

It is proposed that research protocols and both negative and positive results be published, and that researchers have the right to reach independent conclusions even if the results do not support Awqaf New Zealand’s hypotheses. This condition is part of the model’s credibility.

Publication and ownership / An invitation to critique

Scholarly Openness While Protecting the Model’s Rights

The details of the model and its areas of uncertainty are open to scholarly critique, and researchers are encouraged to propose changes and test the hypotheses. Awqaf New Zealand asks for prior written permission before other waqf institutions adopt the Smart Waqf Fund model or use its operational and contractual documents, while the legal rights of research and quotation remain in place.

Before publication, this request must be reconciled with the licence of the paper’s own files; an open licence that allows reuse may conflict with requiring prior permission for some uses. The wording is to be reviewed legally before the DOI deposit.

Scholarly openness and protection of rightsScholarly openness and protection of rightsBalancing publication and protection1Open to critiqueMethod, hypotheses, institutionaldesign, analysis and illustrations2Requires permissionAdopting the model or reusingoperational documents3ProtectedPersonal data, contractual andsensitive informationBefore the Zenodo/DOI deposit: a licence consistent with the permission policy (CC BY may grant wider rights than intended)!Editorial note: What is published and what stays protected is set with the institution’s approval.
Figure 21 Scholarly openness and protection of rightsEditorial illustration · not measured data

Rights, licensing and scholarly publication

A distinction should be made between copyright in the paper’s text and illustrations, the name or distinctive mark of the model, any trade secrets, and contractual rights to use the contract templates. The request for institutional permission is presented as a proposed usage policy that needs legal review, not as absolute protection preventing all reuse or quotation.

Before depositing the paper with Zenodo, a licence consistent with this policy must be chosen; an open licence such as CC BY may grant wider reuse rights than intended, and conflicting conditions must not appear in the research file and on the deposit page.

Source map / Completing the documentation

Core Working References and Evidence Review

Review of evidence and sourcesReview of evidence and sourcesLayers of sources and the verification pathOfficial sourcesLegislation of the seven countries · AAOIFI GS 14 and 15 and Sharia Standard 60 · Academy Resolution 140Review: quote the approved text with paragraph referencesPublished studiesISRA 2016 study · Awqaf New Zealand papers deposited with a DOIReview: establish scope, date and signatoriesInstitutional documentsGoSmart v11 · Maliki forum paper · the book on the differencesReview: separate method, results and agreements!Editorial note: A secondary source is not used in place of an original legal text when stating firm conclusions.
Figure 22 Review of evidence and sourcesEditorial illustration · not measured data
SourceRole in the researchReview required before release
AAOIFI Governance Standard 14Governance of Islamic crowdfundingParagraph references and check against the official version
AAOIFI Governance Standard 15Institutional syndicated financing, where it appliesLimits of applicability and clause-by-clause comparison
Sharia Standard 60 and Academy Resolution 140Grounding for cash waqf and time-limited waqfQuoting the approved texts and analysis without overreach
ISRA study, 2016History of the earlier model and historical endorsementIdentifying names and the scope of signature precisely
Maliki forum paper and the book on the differencesFiqh development and contractual researchDocumenting pages, ideas and points of disagreement
GoSmart v11, the QUI index and published studiesApplied research and the resource measurement methodSeparating method, results and agreements
Legislation of the seven countriesChoosing the jurisdiction of first issuanceCurrent official sources and local legal review

This release is a development version of the design and content, not a peer-reviewed version, a Sharia or legal opinion, or a financial offer document. No DOI is assigned before review is complete and the version is fixed.

Core references and verification pathways

This study relies on primary institutional sources and attached documents, with links to official bodies. The links below were used to identify points for verification; listing a reference must not be read as endorsement of Awqaf New Zealand’s model by the body named.

  1. Awqaf New Zealand, From Awqaf Sukuk to Awqaf Units: Instrument Choice and Accessible Participation in Awqaf New Zealand’s Proposed Cash Waqf Model, institutional working paper, 2026, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23634738.
  2. Awqaf New Zealand, Hijri-Aligned Qurbani Sheep-Dairy Farming: The Economy of the Qurbani Ritual and an Open Invitation to Research, Test and Improve a Proposed Livestock Production System, Discussion Paper No. 1, 2026, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23044284.
  3. Awqaf New Zealand, Feasibility Study: Qurbani Sheep-Dairy Pilot, published version, 2026, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23279953.
  4. Awqaf New Zealand, Qurbani Utilisation Index (QUI-Awqaf NZ): Measuring Zero Qurbani Waste, a Methodology Note for the Qurbani Supply Chain, methodology note, DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.22700036.
  5. Awqaf New Zealand, GoSmart v11, internal development document; used as a reference for proposals while respecting the status of each partnership or project.
  6. ISRA study (2016) of the historical model of temporary and perpetual cash waqf sukuk: published copy of the study; historical endorsement does not automatically extend to later developments.
  7. International Islamic Fiqh Academy, Resolution No. 140 (15/6), on the investment of waqf assets and their yield; the official text is to be consulted for detailed fiqh citation.
  8. AAOIFI, Sharia Standard No. 60, Waqf, and the attached version on time-limited waqf.
  9. AAOIFI, Governance Standard 14 Islamic Crowdfunding Governance and Governance Standard 15 Syndicated Financing, and the two attached versions; official index of standards.
  10. New Zealand Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013, sections 7 and 8, official legislative text.
  11. Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), guidance on fundraising and issuing securities; and the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission (ACNC), fundraising.
  12. Securities Commission Malaysia, guidelines on Islamic capital market products and services, and 2026 updates.
  13. Awqaf New Zealand’s paper to the 18th International Maliki Fiqh Forum, attached version; and the book The Differences Between Temporary Cash Waqf and Cash Qard Hasan, attached version.
  14. The 12th Forum on Waqf Fiqh Issues: the question of the differences between temporary cash waqf and cash qard hasan is before the Forum at Awqaf New Zealand’s request, according to the institution; no decision is attributed to the Forum unless its issuance and text have been verified.
Image appendix / The Awqaf animal family

Appendix: The Awqaf New Zealand Animal Family

Proposed awareness characters; a fictional story, not research findings. Rights for institutional and commercial publication of the images must be confirmed before public use.

Meet the Awqaf Animal Family 1 of 4
Character Collection 1 of 4
Meet the Awqaf Animal Family 2 of 4
Character Collection 2 of 4
Meet the Awqaf Animal Family 3 of 4
Character Collection 3 of 4
Meet the Awqaf Animal Family 4 of 4
Character Collection 4 of 4